Main Topic: The Voice in the Night

While William Hope Hodgson never wrote a Cthulhu Mythos story, his brand of weird fiction complements the Mythos nicely, and Lovecraft himself was a fan. His work ranged from ghost stories that could almost be Scooby-Doo episodes to the wildly cosmic, passing through the uncanny and body horror. And, as with the story we’re discussing today, many drew on Hodgson’s own experiences as a sailor. But what can “The Voice in the Night” tell us that might inspire our Call of Cthulhu games?

Our readings for this episode come from Mike Perceval-Maxwell. You can hear the full story on his podcast, Mr Spike’s Bedtime Stories, along with many other fine classics of weird fiction.

Our Guest Host

We are delighted to welcome Jared Logan back to the Good Friends! Jared is a stand-up comedian and writer who has been involved with a number of major actual play streams and podcasts, including Glass CannonStream of BloodAin’t Slayed Nobody, and Push the Roll With Ross Bryant. You can also find Jared running Vampire: the Masquerade for the good folks behind Last Podcast on the Left.

Jared has previously joined us to discuss:

William Hope Hodgson

Things we mention in this episode include:

News

Patreon Changes Update

We hit a delay on switching over to monthly subscriptions. Patreon need to manually authorise the change and have not yet done so. While this means the September billing was done on the old per-episode model, we anticipate that October will be monthly as planned.

As we mentioned before, we are also taking this opportunity to change from US dollars to British Pounds.

From October 2026, our three basic tiers will be £3, £6 and £10 per month, replacing the old $1, $3 and $5 per-episode tiers. Higher tiers will simply be double the current cost, but in Pounds. This works out as roughly the same cost. The rewards for each tier will also stay the same.

We are currently looking into enabling annual subscriptions and will have more details soon.

Matt at the Innsmouth Literary Festival

Matt will be attending the Innsmouth Literary Festival in Bedford on Saturday the 19th of September. Please do say hi if you find him shambling through the aisles.

Main Topic: Cosy Horror

Horror is usually meant to scare us, but this isn’t always the case. Sometimes it can be oddly comforting — cosy, even. Maybe this is because it’s an old favourite, or perhaps it’s something non-threatening, even hopeful.

So how do we even start defining cosy horror? What are some of the defining works of this subgenre? And how might we bring a touch of cosiness to our own games?

There is some overlap between this and our discussions of horror for the nervous (episode 307) and gateway horror (episode 337), but we take things in a different direction.

Our Guest Host

We are delighted to welcome Holly back to the Good Friends! Holly co-hosts RPG Reanimators, a podcast focusing on providing resources for GMs and players of horror RPGs. She’s also a regular on Into the Darkness, an actual play YouTube channel. In addition to RPGs, she’s an avid board gamer, space nerd, and all-around trivia enthusiast. You can find Holly over on the RPG Reanimators Discord.

Holly has previously joined us to discuss:

Things we mention in this episode include:

News

Patreon Changes

Patreon has announced that they are discontinuing the option for creators to charge per creation (per episode, in our case). This is the model we have always used, as it was the only option available when we started. Instead, we now have switch to a monthly subscription.

We are also taking this opportunity to change from US dollars to British Pounds, as, again, this wasn’t an option when we started.

From September 2026, our three basic tiers will be £3, £6 and £10 per month, replacing the old $1, $3 and $5 per-episode tiers. Higher tiers will simply be double the current cost, but in Pounds. This works out as roughly the same cost. The rewards for each tier will also stay the same.

Existing backers do not need to take any action. The update will happen automatically.

This change additionally allows us to enable annual subscriptions, although we are still looking into these. If this sounds like something you would be interested in, please let us know.

345: Alien

Main Topic: Alien

Since its release in 1979, Alien has become a fan favourite, spawning any number of spin-offs across every medium. But what is the secret of its enduring appeal? How well does it stand up after almost five decades of imitators and pastiches? And what can we take from its strange DNA for our own games?

Our Guest Host

We are delighted to welcome Holly back to the Good Friends! Holly co-hosts RPG Reanimators, a podcast focusing on providing resources for GMs and players of horror RPGs. She’s also a regular on Into the Darkness, an actual play YouTube channel. In addition to RPGs, she’s an avid board gamer, space nerd, and all-around trivia enthusiast. You can find Holly over on the RPG Reanimators Discord.

Holly has previously joined us to discuss:

Things we mention in this episode include:

Tarantula hawk wasp paralysing its prey
(c)Marc Shandro [mshandro@yahoo.com]

News

Patreon Changes

Patreon has announced that they are discontinuing the option for creators to charge per creation (per episode, in our case). This is the model we have always used, as it was the only option available when we started. Instead, we now have switch to a monthly subscription.

We are also taking this opportunity to change from US dollars to British Pounds, as, again, this wasn’t an option when we started.

From September 2026, our three basic tiers will be £3, £6 and £10 per month, replacing the old $1, $3 and $5 per-episode tiers. Higher tiers will simply be double the current cost, but in Pounds. This works out as roughly the same cost. The rewards for each tier will also stay the same.

This change additionally allows us to enable annual subscriptions, although we are still looking into these. If this sounds like something you would be interested in, please let us know.

Thank You to ENnie Voters

While we didn’t end up winning an ENnie award this year, we would still like to thank everyone who voted for us. Just being nominated was amazing, and we were moved by all the support from listeners. It’s all been rather wonderful.

Main Topic: Why You Shouldn’t Learn to Roleplay From Actual Plays

Actual play podcasts and streams have grown in popularity massively over the past 20 years, redefining and dominating the hobby. They play a huge role in bringing people into roleplaying games, and possibly an even larger one in teaching new players how they work. But is this always a good thing? What are the advantages and possible pitfalls of learning from APs? And what other approaches might we recommend?

This episode was recorded live at A Weekend With Good Friends 2026. While it mostly follows the usual format, we do spend a bit of time towards the end answering questions from people who were watching live. You can see the video for this and all the other seminars on the AWWGF YouTube Channel.

Our Guest Host

We are delighted to welcome Zach Reeves back to The Good Friends of Jackson Elias! Zach is the game master, producer, and editor of Pretending to be People, a horror/comedy actual play podcast. Zach enjoys karaoke with his wife, dancing with friends, and creating elaborate scavenger hunts. He is afraid of losing his mind and Styrofoam.

Pretending to be People will be appearing live at Gen Con 2026, at 4 PM on Friday the 31st. Tickets are still available. There will also be meetups throughout the con, so keep an eye out for those.

Zach has previously joined us to discuss:

Things we mention in this episode include:

Critical Role
The Glass Cannon Network, with at least three Good Friends co-hosts

News

2HS on HWR

After 9 1/2 years, How We Roll have recorded the final episodes of The Two-Headed Serpent. This has been an epic journey, and Scott would like to thank everyone who took part, specifically Joe, Dave, Kuran, Camille, Liisa, Aron, Eoghan, and Mav. Oh, and Greg, of course.

These last episodes will come out over the course of the next few months. Expect death, destruction, and sheer bloody chaos.

Now for a short rest before the inevitable sequel.

Main Topic: Reactive GMing

No game ever goes to plan. Whether you have prepared for every eventuality or are running off the cuff, players will always do the unexpected. Improvisation is a key skill for GMs, from spinning narrative on the fly to incorporating whatever chaos the players come up with.

But what are some of the key techniques in making this work? How do you learn to let go as a GM? And are there ever times when you might want to keep a grip on the reins?

We have discussed similar topics in earlier episodes on player-led games and improvisation.

This episode was recorded live at A Weekend With Good Friends 2026. While it mostly follows the usual format, we do spend a bit of time towards the end answering questions from people who were watching live. You can see the video for this and all the other seminars on the AWWGF YouTube Channel.

Our Guest Host

We are delighted to welcome Ross Bryant back as our guest host for this episode. You may know Ross from The Improvised Shakespeare CompanyDropout TVThe Glass Cannon Network, or the many Call of Cthulhu games he and Scott have played together on Ain’t Slayed Nobody.

Most recently, Ross has launched his own podcast, called Push the Roll With Ross Bryant, where he runs fully improvised games of Call of Cthulhu, based on listener suggestions, for various friends from the worlds of comedy, improv, and tabletop gaming. You can find it wherever you get your podcasts.

Ross is currently in residence with The Improvised Shakespeare Company at the Denver Center for the Performing Arts until the 27th of July.

Ross has previously joined us to discuss:

Things we mention in this episode include:

Play Unsafe cover

News

ENnie Nomination

We were delighted to hear that The Good Friends of Jackson Elias has been nominated for an ENnie Award in the Best Streaming Content category. This is exciting and entirely unexpected. The Good Friends has been running for over 13 years now and we’re just happy that people are still listening!

The awards themselves are decided through a public vote. If you are a fan of the podcast and you’d like to vote for us (and earn our undying gratitude), you can find the form here. Voting runs between the 10th and 19th of July 2026.